What’s the deal with your watery apple pie? How Can It Be Fixed?

Rate this post

Apple pie is a tasty and delectable dish. Apple pie is the golden middle between the joys of cooking and eating. It is simple to create and much more tasty. But, as lovely as this sounds, apple pie may be watery, reducing your pleasure. So, what’s the deal with your watery apple pie, and how can you solve it?

Watery apple pie may be caused by using overripe apples, failing to make vents in the top crust, removing the pie too soon, blending the apples instead of cutting them, failing to soak the apples, and failing to add thickeners. One option to repair it is to put it back in the oven.

Regrettably, I have many tales about leaky apple pie, so I explored and tried to discover the right recipe so that I could enjoy my apple pies without having to deal with a fluid filling. In the following paragraphs, I will discuss the causes of a runny pie, how to avoid and correct it, and the optimal time to serve your pie.

Why Is Your Apple Pie Watery?

Your pie is watery for a number of reasons. Since it is a fruity treat, apple pie is more likely to be watery than other pies, such as meaty pies. Apple pie, on the other hand, isn’t watery just because it’s a fruit pie; there are various additional aspects to consider.

Overripe Apples

The conventional rule is that you may use whichever apples you choose in an apple pie, however this isn’t fully correct. Even though you are free to pick the sort of apple, you need pay particular attention to its maturity. Utilizing overripe apples contributes significantly to a watery apple pie.

The more liquid the apples release, the more liquid they leak, therefore to prevent a watery apple pie, first and foremost, pick your apples wisely. Choosing excellent, solid apples can assist you prevent having too much liquid in your apple pie.

Blending the Apples

How you chop your apples is another issue that determines whether your pie will be watery or not. If you blend them, the pie will be liquid, so slice them into little bits instead. The apple pieces preserve their integrity, structure, and liquid-retaining linkages.

Blended apples have dissolved and will continue to release liquid because they lack the consistency required to keep it.

Not Soaking the Apples

Adding another step to the apple pie-making procedure isn’t everyone’s favorite notion, but soaking the apples reduces the likelihood of a watery apple pie.

By soaking the apple pieces in sugar for approximately an hour before placing them in the dough, you can get a compact and firm apple pie. Stirring them will also assist to evaporate the surplus liquid.

Not Using Cold Ingredients

Preparing your apple pie without chilling the dough and filling beforehand can result in a runny apple pie. If the apple filling is not chilled before constructing the pie, it will create more moisture during baking, which the crust will be unable to absorb without becoming soggy.

Not Using Thickener

If your apple filling has no thickening agents, it will most likely turn watery. Thickeners like cornstarch or other thickeners absorb moisture, resulting in a firm, compact apple filling. Also, the more moisture the thickening absorbs, the less moisture is left for the crust, which means your crust will retain the filling well.

Not Making Vents on the Top Crust

Topping your pie without first putting vents in the top crust is a recipe for catastrophe. The moisture produced by your apple filling will be trapped behind the crust and absorbed back into the apples. In addition, your crust will be quite wet, and you will wind up boiling your pie rather than baking it.

Taking Your Apple Pie out of the Oven Too Soon

The last step, if you performed everything correctly, is to bake your pie. The golden tint of the top crust indicates that the pie is ready to be removed. You notice that the pie is watery after it’s out, which suggests you pulled it out too soon.

Putting your pie in the oven for five to ten minutes longer will make a significant impact, so don’t skimp on cooking time.

Cutting Your Pie Too Soon

As you remove your pie from the oven, it will require some time to set. Cutting your pie while it is still setting is a major cause of watery pie. Even if you followed all of the instructions and did everything possible to prevent a runny pie, cutting it too soon can cause the contents to fall out, resulting in a sloppy and shapeless dessert.

How to Fix a Watery Apple Pie?

If, despite your best efforts, your pie still comes out watery, there are two steps you may do to remedy the situation.

Back to the Oven

If your apple pie is too watery, bake it for another 5 to 10 minutes at 302 F. It’s a good idea to poke a few additional holes in the crust to allow the surplus liquid to drain. The extended baking time will dry your pie and decrease the moisture in the filling.

Put your pie on the bottom oven rack rather than the middle or top. This allows the apple filling to thicken without scorching the crust.

Additional Fridge Time 

Whether it’s watery or not, apple pie has to chill before serving. Allowing your apple pie to cool for longer can thicken the filling and allow it to set better. After all, the tastiest apple pie is served cold.

Let your pie to cool completely before putting it in the refrigerator. Refrigerating your pie immediately after taking it out of the oven can make matters worse.

How to Prevent Watery Apple Pie Next Time While Baking?

Watery apple pie is avoidable, so the next time you cook it, you won’t have to worry about too much moisture in your dessert.

Make sure your apple filling has enough cornstarch or similar thickening agent. The Thickener will do its work, providing you with a satisfying dessert experience.

You may also preheat the oven to 302 F for 15 minutes before baking, and use everything cold, from the ingredients to the baking pan. If your filling, crust, and baking pan are cold when you place them in the oven, the quick temperature shift will dry your pie first, leaving less moisture to be released later.

Cooking the filling ahead of time allows the extra liquid to drain. You may avoid your pie from getting watery by boiling the apple filling for 15 minutes.

Let your pie to cool for a whole day or overnight. Once your pie has naturally cooled, cover it with aluminum foil and store it in the refrigerator for at least five hours. To keep your pie from absorbing moisture from the fridge, place it on the highest shelf.

How Long Does Apple Pie Take to Set?

The setting time for your apple pie should be between two and three hours. You just let your pie on the counter to cool on its own. Don’t cover it or cut it; simply let it alone.

The preparation of your apple pie does not finish when you remove it from the oven; the following stages are also necessary. You must allow time for your apple pie to set once it has been removed from the oven.

The setting is critical since it is where everything you’ve done before comes together. All of the elements you utilized are now combining to form a single entity. Interfering with the setup procedure will only end in tragedy.

When the apple pie has set, store it in the refrigerator. Cover the pie with aluminum foil and place it in the refrigerator for at least three hours. It is better to keep it on the top shelf to avoid gathering moisture from the fridge’s air.

How Long Should Pie Set Before Cutting?

You may carve your pie two to three hours after it has been removed from the oven. Nevertheless, just because you can does not mean you should. It is preferable to carve your pie once it has set and chilled thoroughly in the refrigerator.

If you don’t want to wait four to six hours to sample your pie, you may cut it without refrigerating it as long as you follow the required setting time.

How to Cool Apple Pie Quickly?

Cooling your apple pie in a hurry should never be your first choice. It must cool down naturally and gradually.

If you are in a rush and need to chill your pie fast, you may shorten the setting time. Instead of two to three hours, let your pie to set for around 30 to 40 minutes. If the temperature in your fridge is higher than 41 degrees Fahrenheit, reduce it before placing your pie inside. Refrigerate the apple pie for as long as possible, but no less than an hour.


How do you thicken watery apple pie filling?

There are various ways for thickening a fruit pie filling. Often, flour or cornstarch are used, although tapioca, arrowroot, and potato starch may also be used to obtain the proper consistency.

Why did my pie come out soupy?

Take attention to bake times: one of the main reasons for a runny fruit pie is that it wasn’t cooked long enough. Whatever thickening you use will take some time to firm up, and folks often see their crust become light brown and believe the pie is done when it isn’t.

Can I Rebake a soggy pie?

How to Restore a Soggy Pie Crust. Often, the top crust of a pie will cook quicker than the bottom crust. If the bottom crust is underdone, cover it with foil to prevent it from burning and return your pie to the oven at 425oF to 450oF for approximately 12 minutes.

Can I put an apple pie back in the oven?

How should an apple pie be reheated in the oven? Place the pie, cut or whole, on a parchment-lined baking sheet and bake for approximately 15 minutes at 350°F. Feel the crust to make sure it’s warmed and toasted enough for you; if not, continue heating in five to ten minute intervals.

How long does it take for apple pie filling to thicken?

Each fruit cup requires 4 tablespoons of instant tapioca. 2 to 3 As a result, if you’re using it as a thickening in your apple pie, let it rest for 15 to 30 minutes before baking. You may use 1 cup for a fruit pie filling.

Does cornstarch thicken apple pie?

Flour, cornstarch, and tapioca aid to thicken pie fillings and protect them from becoming a watery mess. Apples do not produce as much liquid as berries and hence need less thickener. With an apple pie, both flour and cornstarch work nicely.

Can you put a pie back in the oven after cooling?

Furthermore, allow the pie to cool for at least 4 hours before slicing and serving. If it’s too late, you may put the pie back in the oven provided it hasn’t been out for too long. Cover the pie with foil and bake at 425°F for 15 minutes, checking after that.

How do you fix watery apple crisp?

Why is my apple crisp so wet? To thicken the apple juices into a sauce, you’ll need to add flour and baking powder.

Should you cook apples before making apple pie?

Remember that precooking the apples is the key to a superb apple pie filling. This ensures flawless uniformity and a well-balanced sweetness. You’ll also eliminate the space between the crust and the filling.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *