What Sauce Goes with Turkey Sandwich? 11 Perfect Combos

Rate this post

The turkey sandwich has become the go-to delicacy when you want something nice and fast. It is beloved by many and a regular guest in practically any family. A turkey sandwich has several garnishing possibilities to enhance its flavor. So, what sauce should I serve with the turkey sandwich?

Mayo, mustard, cranberry sauce, salsa sauce, crème fraiche and parmesan, tartar sauce, or mayo and sour cream sauce are all options for the turkey sandwich. However, there are some more healthy choices.

It’s a great idea to put sauce on your turkey sandwich. Although the turkey sandwich goes well with many tastes, it does not go with everything. To prevent your turkey sandwich from going to waste because you used the incorrect sauce, I will explore turkey sandwich sauces as well as provide some healthy sauce choices in this post.

What Sauces Go Good on Turkey Sandwich?

Turkey sandwiches go well with a variety of sauces and sauce combinations.The important thing to remember is to choose thick sauces so that they do not make the bread soggy if placed within the sandwich, and creamy sauces if served on the side.


With the addition of pepper and blended dried tomato, mustard becomes a sauce rather than a simple condiment, much like mayo.If you like basic mustard, there’s nothing wrong with that, but spicing it up is always a good idea.

In addition, you may combine mustard and honey to make a quick dip, or combine mustard and ketchup to spread inside a turkey sandwich.


The wonderful thing about mayo is that it is simply mayo when it is out of the jar, but when you add a few spices, such as herbs, curry, and powdered garlic, it becomes a sauce.

You will surely like spiced mayo as a turkey sandwich sauce, whether you spread it inside your turkey sandwich or serve it on a separate saucer on the side. I recommend mayo with herbal spices and a few drops of lemon juice if you have it on the side, or mayo with curry and powdered garlic if you smear it inside.

Salsa Sauce 

There’s nothing like a refreshing, delicious, and spicy salsa sauce to amp up the taste of your turkey sandwich.Don’t be afraid to eat as much as you like since the flavor of the tomatoes, onions, peppers, and exquisite spices will bring out the best in your turkey sandwich.

I’d suggest serving the salsa sauce in a separate saucer since it’s really juicy and will likely saturate your bread. If you wish to apply some salsa sauce on the interior of the sandwich, thicken it with parmesan or grated cheese.

Crème Fraiche and Parmesan 

Crème Fraiche and parmesan are an excellent way to add freshness, tanginess, and flavor to your turkey sandwich.The mix of cheesy and milky flavors intermingled with the sharpness and mild sourness of crème fraiche and the richness of parmesan is an exceptionally delightful way to elevate your turkey sandwich.

The parmesan will also thicken and absorb the moisture in the crème fraiche, making this sauce perfect to pour over your turkey flesh and serve on the side. The crme Fraiche combination is also adaptable to a variety of flavorings, so feel free to experiment.

Tartar Sauce 

Nothing beats good old-fashioned tartar sauce on occasion.The richness of the mayo and the finely chopped pickles offer a very rich taste to anything you serve it with. Smear it inside your turkey sandwich, serve it on the side, or eat it both ways!

The mild herbal flavor of the tartar sauce is an added treat, making your turkey sandwich a really unforgettable experience.

Cranberry Sauce 

Something about the combo of cranberry sauce and turkey is intoxicating.Cranberry sauce atop turkey meat on a sandwich is like a little Thanksgiving feast. You’ll receive that pleasant, warm Christmas sensation in your tongue right away and need more of the same.

I’d suggest putting the cranberry sauce inside your sandwich and allowing the flavors combine to create a fresh festive taste explosion.

Mayo and Sour Cream Sauce 

The mayo and sour cream sauce will tempt your taste senses in ways you never believed possible.The creamy mayo coupled with the acidic sour cream creates a smooth and silky concoction that you will find difficult to resist.

Spice it up anyway you like and eat it however you want; it works nicely speared and served on a separate saucer.

Healthy Sauces for Turkey Sandwich

Healthy isn’t usually synonymous with bland, but the two might often overlap.When it comes to healthy sauces for your turkey sandwich, you don’t have to settle for the boring and commonplace; there are some tasty and nutritious alternatives.


The marinara sauce is brimming with tomato charm and herbal enchantment, and it’s a great accompaniment to your turkey sandwich.However, since the marinara sauce is somewhat sloppy, I recommend serving it on the side on a separate saucer.


Guacamole is a wonderfully nutritious sauce choice that comes in an infinite number of variations.You just need avocado as a required ingredient and some onions and peppers to liven it up. Because the avocado is the fundamental component for the unseasoned guacamole sauce, it has a neutral flavor that is ideal for flavoring anyway you wish.

Smear the guacamole on top of your sandwich and enjoy the refreshing guacamole flavor that will delightfully surprise your taste senses.


Although it is not a sauce in the traditional sense, hummus cannot be overlooked when discussing healthful smearable additives.The beauty of hummus is that it goes well with practically every taste combination, from meat to veggies to cheese, making it an excellent accompaniment to a turkey sandwich.

Cottage Cheese With Olive Oil and Nuts

This sauce includes protein, lacto bacteria, and healthy fats, but it’s not only about nutrition; it also tastes great.Whip the cottage cheese by hand and drizzle with olive oil to make it more creamier. Smear it inside your turkey sandwich with some nuts and salt to taste.


What condiment is good on a turkey sandwich?

Cheese – Flavorful cheeses, such as Pepper Jack Cheese, are often used as condiments to enhance the taste of a sandwich. Cranberry Sauce – This sauce complements turkey sandwiches well!! Guacamole – Guacamole goes well with sandwiches.

What can I put on a turkey sandwich besides mayo?

If You Don’t Like Mayo or Pesto, Try These Spreads Instead. PIN IT. Julia Maguire took the photo.
Hummus. PIN IT. Parisa Soraya took the photo.
Avocado. PIN IT. Samantha Thayer took the photo.
Mustard Mustard. PIN IT. The image is courtesy of yemekye.com.
Yogurt from Greece. PIN IT. Lauryn Lahr took the photo.
Butter. PIN IT.
Dips that have been left over. PIN IT.
Fruit preserves or jam. PIN IT.

What goes good with turkey sandwich?

Here are ten of our favorite sides to go with it:
Salad with Pomegranate and Dried Cranberries.
2 – Celeriac Puree.
Crispy Zucchini Fritters (3rd).
Soup with Tomatoes and Basil.
5 – Roasted Acorn Squash.
Casserole with Green Beans and Bacon.
Sweet potatoes candied to perfection.
Cranberry-Maple Cornbread (no. 8).

Which sauce is best for sandwich?

I’ve provided recipes for four of them, all of which need just five ingredients or fewer!
1 – Mayonnaise with honey mustard. Let’s begin with a classic: honey mustard mayo! …
2 – Pesto. Next up is one of my personal favorites: PESTO! …
Chipotle mayonnaise, number three.
Spicy Avocado (4th).
4 – Cream cheese with chives.
6 – Jam.

What tastes good with turkey?

What Should You Serve With Turkey?
Yams candied.
Mashed potatoes with roasted garlic cream sauce.
Mashed Potatoes with Garlic Red Skin.
Green Beans that have been roasted.
Brussel Sprouts with Balsamic Glaze.
Carrots in the microwave.
Green Bean and Bacon Casserole.
Baked Cauliflower with Cheesy Sauce.

What condiment goes best with turkey and cheese?

If you want a taste of Thanksgiving, try cranberry sauce. If you want something simple and straightforward, honey Dijon mustard and mayonnaise should suffice.

What can I put on turkey besides gravy?

Try these sauces on your Thanksgiving turkey, sweet potatoes, or even your Thanksgiving tacos!
Georgian Plum Sauce Tkemali.
Chutney with pears and peppers.
Jam with boozy bacon.
Applesauce with Cranberries.
Bourbon BBQ Sauce from scratch.
Chimichurri sauce created from scratch.
Mango Chutney Aam Ki Launji.
BBQ sauce with blueberries.

Is Ranch good on a turkey sandwich?

Enjoy this filling turkey sandwich with Swiss cheese, bacon, and ranch dressing. Combine mayonnaise and dressing; spread over cut sides of bread. Fill with the rest of the ingredients. To complete off the dinner, serve with a side salad and a piece of fruit.

Does mayonnaise go with turkey?

You may think slathering mayonnaise on turkey before roasting is strange, but it’s the ideal technique to insulate the flesh. The mayonnaise rub is made out of fresh chopped herbs and spices, and the thick viscosity helps the herbs stick to the chicken.

What is the most famous sandwich in turkey?

Kumru is a Turkish sandwich served on a bread that often includes cheese, tomato, and sausage. The name of this street dish translates as ‘collared dove’ and refers to the form of the sandwich. The original kumru was fashioned like a ring and coated with sesame seeds.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *