Scooter Pie vs. Moon Pie: What’s the Different and Which Is Better?

Rate this post

Moon Pies and Scooter Pies are sweet childhood memories for many Americans. I’m sure everyone has eaten these chocolate sweets and been pleasantly pleased by their deliciousness. Yet the issue is, were these two items identical? If not, what made them different?

The Chattanooga Bakery’s Moon Pies are a trademarked product, and the Scooter Pie is a variant of the Moon Pie. A marshmallow filling is placed between two graham crackers in both products. The original maker continues to create moon pies, but scooter pies have been discontinued.

In this post, we’ll go back in time to learn how two iconic midday treats came to be.

Scooter Pie vs. Moon Pie: Differences


There seems to be some debate over the origins of these two goods and which emerged first. Nonetheless, most people think that Moon Pies were the first to popularize the cookie sandwich with marshmallow filling idea, which spawned other offshoots and varieties, including the Scooter Pie.

The origins of Moon Pies are an intriguing tale. According to the official story, Earl Mitchel, a traveling salesman, questioned a Kentucky coal miner about his favorite snack. In his own words, the miner envisioned a snack the size of the moon.

Mitchel was inspired and returned to his job at Chattanooga Bakery. The bakery made the first Moon Pie in response to this fantastical request. This occurred in 1917.

Scooter Pies, a twist on the original Moon Pie idea, became popular a few decades later. The moniker is said to be derived from New York shortstop Phil Scooter Rizzuto, who eventually became renowned as a radio broadcaster. It’s unknown why he picked this moniker, but it surely drew notice in the 1960s and 1970s.

Manufacturers created Scooter Pies under numerous company names throughout the years. They’ve been discontinued, and it’s difficult to find any items on any platform.

Taste and Texture

Scooter Pies have long been discontinued, making a modern comparison between Scooter Pies and Moon Pies difficult. All pies feature the same basic concept: two graham cracker slices cover a center of marshmallow cream. The whole item is then dipped in chocolate.

Many individuals in the Northern United States believe that Scooter Pies are the best snack.


If you were a youngster growing up in the 1970s, you could tell these two goods simply by looking at them. The graham crackers in both pies were chocolate-coated.

The chocolate on Moon Pies, on the other hand, is a deeper, darker shade. The Scooter Pies, on the other hand, featured a lighter colored chocolate covering that resembled caramel candy. Scooter Pies were similarly rougher on the outside than Moon Pies.


All Moon Pies are packed and delivered in boxes ranging in size from 6 to 36. Within the box, each pie is wrapped in a transparent plastic bag. The Moon Pie logo is an easy way to recognize this product. The majority of the boxes are blue and white in color.

Scooter Pies, on the other hand, had changing packaging throughout the years as ownership changed. They also came in a variety of colors, depending on which firm made them. Several corporate logos accompanied these pies, ranging from Capn Crunch to Salerno.


Moon Pies have grown in popularity dramatically since its creation in 1917. Manufacturers were packing hundreds of these goods by the end of the decade. As the popularity of this food expanded, so did this figure. The Moon pies were so popular among the American people that they were even used as a source of consolation during World War II.

Moon Pies are now available in most states and most prominent retail locations, both online and offline. The Chattanooga Bakery manufactures over 300,000 of these delectable treats every day, which are delivered to different regions of the United States.

Throughout the 1960s and 1970s, the Scooter Pie gained a household name. They were notably common in the northern United States. Scooter pies become a favorite lunchtime treat for many youngsters.

Yet, the product gradually lost its importance over the years. Scooter Pie, unlike Moon Pie, has been managed by many corporations in the past, including an Italian-based maker around the turn of the century. Scooter Pie manufacturing eventually came to an end.


The Chattanooga Bakery has created several modifications on its traditional recipe throughout the years. They’ve purchased single-decker, double-decker, and little pies. Moon Pies are available in chocolate, vanilla, banana, butterscotch, caramel, and strawberry flavors.

Scooter Pies have never had such a wide range of tastes. Yet, there were some. A version included more chocolate in the marshmallow filling. Salerno has previously offered a banana-flavored Scooter Pie.

Scooter Pie Vs. Moon Pie: Which Is Better?

Moon Pies come in a considerably wider range of flavors and are widely accessible. These are inexpensive but filling, simple yet tasty delicacies that may serve as a midday meal or an afternoon snack. Moon Pies will remain the preferable option until a new business restarts manufacture of Scooter Pies.

  • What Is the Different Between a Whoopie Pie and a Moon Pie?

Are Scooter Pies Still Made?

Regrettably, manufacture of Scooter Pies ceased sometime in the early 2000s. They were never as well-known or readily available as Moon Pies. Eventually, other firms were inspired by the Moon Pie concept and began producing similar items. As a result, demand decreased over time.

Why Are Moon Pies so Cheap?

The Moon Pies’ key selling point was their low price. It became a lunchtime favourite for both students and employees since it was both filling and affordable.

The reason for this is the cheap manufacturing cost. The majority of the Moon Pie components, including the marshmallow filling and graham crackers, are affordable, particularly when made in quantity.

Scooter Pies are a bygone age artifact, a joyful reminiscence of many people’s youth. But, Moon Pies are a part of that youth that has endured and continues to thrill children and adults alike.


Are moon pies the same as scooter pies?

Scooter Pies are a Moon Pie variation named after New York Yankees infielder Phil “Scooter” Rizzuto. They consist of two graham-like crackers sandwiching a layer of chocolate-covered marshmallow.

Are scooter pies still made?

There’s also a double-decker pie with a third biscuit inside and an extra layer of marshmallows. The Scooter Pie was only available in 4-inch sizes. The Chattanooga Bakery Co. continues to make the little cookie pies.

What snacks are similar to moonpies?

A comparable product known as a “Scooter Pie” and a single-cracker marshmallow biscuit known as “Mallomars” are available in northern parts of the United States. Little Debbie also sells “Marshmallow Pies,” which are essentially similar to moon pies.

Is there another name for moon pies?

Whoopie pies are a delicious dessert formed with moist, cookie-shaped cakes layered over a creamy filling. They are also known as gobs, bobs, black-and-whites, “big giant Oreos,” and occasionally “moon pies.”

What are the different types of moon pies?

Moonpies are typically available in five flavors: chocolate, vanilla, banana, strawberry, and salted caramel.

What is the original Moon Pie?

According to legend, the first Moonpie — a graham cracker cookie and marshmallow sandwich coated in chocolate and four inches in diameter — was created in 1917 by traveling salesman Earl Mitchell in response to the hungry pleadings of local miners.

Who owns MoonPie?

Chattanooga Bakery, Inc. is the firm behind the MoonPie, the South’s most renowned dessert. This marshmallow and cookie sandwich became so popular as a cheap treat that it was immortalized in songs, novels, and even a festival or two.

Are moon pies unhealthy?

Double Decker Moon Pie

Since 1917, the Moon Pie cake has been a popular dessert choice. Although we admire the chocolate marshmallow sandwich for its popularity, it’s not always a healthy option, since one pie has 300 calories and over 30 grams of sugar.

Who makes the little pies for Walmart?

Walmart’s own label, 74-cent Freshness Guaranteed, The Bakery collection pies are made by Table Talk Pies. Table Top Pies manufactures 250 million pies every year, with 185 million pies going to Walmart.

Are MoonPies healthy?

According to the Finaflex website, they’re a terrific alternative for anybody trying to enhance their daily protein consumption. MoonPies have been around for more than a century.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *