How Should You Reheat Lemon Meringue Pie? First, read this!

Lemon meringue pie is a refreshing and delightful dessert. However, it has a lot of fats and carbohydrates, so you probably won’t consume it all in one sitting. As a result, you must find an alternative to tossing away the remaining pie. So, how do you reheat lemon meringue?

Keep the lemon meringue pie in the oven at 250 F for 15 minutes to warm. Nevertheless, you should not reheat lemon meringue pie since it is not meant to be served hot. If the lemon custard has already cooled completely before topping it with the meringue, you will need to reheat the custard-filled crust.

Although though you don’t really need to reheat a lemon meringue pie since it tastes wonderful at room temperature, I’ll describe how to reheat it, how to avoid it from becoming soggy, whether or not you can eat it the next day, and how to store it correctly in the following paragraphs.

How to Reheat Lemon Meringue Pie?

As previously stated, you do not reheat your lemon meringue pie. But, there are two scenarios in which you could do so.

Since the custard should be hot when topped with the meringue, reheat the custard-filled crust if it has become cold. To correctly connect the meringue and custard when put together, prepare them both at the same time.

If you can’t get the time correct for any reason, and you’ve already filled the crust with custard, reheat the pie before adding the meringue. Slowly reheat the pie at a moderate temperature of no more than 250F, gradually increasing it. This should take around 10-15 minutes, and keep the pie close to the top heater to keep the custard warm without burning the crust.

Another situation in which you may reheat your lemon meringue pie is if you just want to eat or serve it warm. You don’t have to do this, however, since the pie will be fine at room temperature or cold.

Please reheat the lemon meringue pie at a low temperature and leave it in the oven for ten minutes. Please do not raise the temperature, and once removed, cover the pie with a towel. This will keep the meringue from becoming sticky and the crust from becoming too hard to bite.

How Do You Prevent Your Lemon Meringue Pie from Getting Soggy?

Lemon meringue pies are notorious for becoming mushy. Thankfully, there are steps you may do to avoid or correct this situation.

The most important step is to prebake the crust. The crust will dehydrate and become significantly less absorbent, leaving you with a hard and dry foundation to begin with.

Another thing to remember is to remove your pie from the oven as soon as it is done. Allowing it to sit in the oven will result in a mushy pie due to the vapor absorption.

Filling should be thickened using cornstarch. If the filling isn’t thick enough, the crust will absorb the liquid, resulting in a mushy pie.

Use a fireproof glass platter to bake your pie. This allows your pie to absorb heat from the oven quicker, reducing baking time and decreasing the likelihood of your pie accumulating vapor.

Bake your pie in the bottom part of the oven, where the crust will be near the heaters, drying it quicker and reducing the likelihood of sogginess.

Next, after removing the pie, let it to cool and cover it with a towel. This manner, your pie will be rich and creamy without becoming soggy.

Covering your pie with plastic wrap can make it extremely wet, so avoid doing so. Aluminum foil should be used to cover your pie in the fridge, since it has the same effect as plastic wrap.

If you must cover your pie with aluminum foil, be sure to poke a few holes in it so that moisture does not accumulate underneath the foil. This method does not work with plastic wrap since it is designed to retain moisture.

Can You Serve Lemon Meringue Pie the Next Day?

Serve your lemon meringue pie the same day you prepare it. If you must cook it the day before, you may serve it the following day, but keep a few things in mind.

Cover and keep your lemon meringue pie at room temperature until the following day, but no longer. You may also store it in the fridge, but remember to cover it with aluminum foil.

You may store your pie in the refrigerator for up to three days. Refrigeration, on the other hand, might make your pie runny because it absorbs the moist air from the fridge, so put it on the top shelf.

Put your pie in the fridge for a couple of hours before serving to achieve the best results. If you don’t want to chill it, keep it at room temperature until ready to serve (not more than a day at most).

If you want to serve your lemon meringue pie warm, place it in a low-temperature oven for 10-15 minutes before serving. Remember to let the pie remain at room temperature for an hour before warming it up.