How Much Should a Handmade Pumpkin Pie Cost?

Rate this post

Nothing screams Thanksgiving quite like a classic pumpkin pie. The greatest thing is that you don’t have to wait until Thanksgiving to enjoy this delectable dessert. When you offer this dish on your menu, you may anticipate high demand. So, how much should a handmade pumpkin pie cost?

A 9-inch handmade pumpkin pie may cost between $23 and $30, which includes the costs of supplies, labor, utilities, and packing. This pie may be cut into 8 equal pieces and sold for $2 to $4 per piece.

Pumpkin pies are popular, particularly during the holidays. Including them on your menu is a smart approach to boost your bakery’s attractiveness. And in this post, we’ll look at how much it costs to produce a single pumpkin pie and how to sell them.

How Much Should You Charge for Homemade Pumpkin Pie?

While determining the pricing of your product, you must consider the cost of the materials and packaging, as well as your labor, power expenses, and the cost of equipment (if they are substantial). Shipping expenses must also be considered if the goods is to be delivered to a remote location.

A normal pumpkin pie costs between $10 and $11 in ingredients. It would cost $1.27 to package the pies in a square bakery box with a window.

It takes around an hour to create the pie. The labor cost might range from $10 and $15 per hour, depending on how much you want to charge for your job. You must also pay for utilities and equipment.

After accounting for all of this plus a profit margin, you should charge between $23 and $30 for your baked pumpkin pie. This is before any shipping charges are applied. It is largely dependent on the delivery method and the destination.

The precise cost of the product will depend on how much you spend on the different components and packaging. You may add unusual ingredients to give your pies a unique flavor and complexity. You may also use a complex packing strategy to enhance its aesthetic attractiveness.

How Much Does It Cost to Make a Homemade Pumpkin Pie?

Many factors are considered when calculating the cost of manufacturing a handmade baked goods. Not only will the cost of individual components vary, but various individuals will cook their own versions of the pie.

Hence, for this calculation, we’ll use a recipe for a simple but delicious pumpkin pie. The goal here is to give you a ballpark figure for the cost of producing a handmade pumpkin pie using basic components.

  • $0.80 for a cup of Crisco shortening
  • 3 c. all-purpose flour (King Arthurs) $0.511 and 1
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 3 tablespoons cold water
  • $2.62 for 1 can of Pumpkin Puree
  • 1 can (Nestle) evaporated milk $1.57
  • 2 eggs $0.82
  • 1 cup brown sugar (Domino Dark Brown Sugar) $2.64
  • $0.97 for 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

Of course, you may add spices such as ginger, cinnamon, and nutmeg to make a pie. The overall cost of all the components is $10, although this varies depending on shop pricing and ingredient quality. This will create a pie 8 to 9 inches in diameter. This pie may be cut into 8 equal pieces for 8 servings. Thus, baking a single piece of pie would cost around $1.30.

How Much to Charge for a Slice Homemade Pumpkin Pie?

If you want to sell a full pie for $20 to $30, a single slice will cost between $2.5 and $4, assuming the pie is divided into 8 equal halves. Since the pie pieces will need to be individually wrapped and delivered, the sum of its parts will be larger than the whole.

How Do You Package Homemade Pumpkin Pie?

The most difficult aspect of operating a bakery from home is the packing and shipping procedure. You want the packaging to appear nice, but it can’t be so pricey that it drives up the price of the pie too much. As a result, there must be a balance.

A bakery box with a window is the finest way to deliver a pie. These boxes are made of paperboard and feature a window part coated with clear plastic film. This is a convenient method of delivering handmade pies.

The boxes are readily disposable and inexpensive, and the window lets buyers to view the content, which you can use to your advantage. You can acquire ornate boxes with attractive decorations, but if you overspend, a plain box with a window will suffice.

It is recommended to purchase these boxes in bulk since it is less expensive. You may simply get these from Amazon or Walmart. However, you might approach any local producers of similar items, which would be a less expensive option.

How Do You Sell Homemade Pumpkin Pie?

If you want to sell your handmade items, you must first identify a market for them that you can readily reach. Contact your local farmers market or supermarket shops that offer handmade foods. You may acquire a contract to provide the retailer a certain quantity of pies to sell on your behalf.

Alternately, you may use multiple social media platforms to develop an online platform. Potential purchasers may see your pies and other items here.

The greatest place to begin such an initiative would be with close friends and acquaintances. Begin selling the pies locally and brand your home bakery. With the present state of the globe, you might consider developing an internet platform where people may purchase your pies.

To summarize, a pumpkin pie is the ideal comfort pie since it is meaty, sweet, and quaint. You can’t go wrong with a nice pumpkin pie to brighten up a Thanksgiving dinner table or a regular supper with company.


How much does a pumpkin pie sell for?

Store-bought pumpkin pie comes at a variety of pricing ranges, ranging from frozen pies like Marie Callender’s, which cost about $6-$7, to higher-quality pies available at farmers’ markets and fantastic bakeries, which can cost well over $20.

How much pumpkin pie per person?

Cooking For Crowds recommends that one 3-inch slice of pumpkin, sweet potato, or apple pie equals one serving. Hence, depending on how much dessert your guests like, two or three 9-inch pies might feed a gathering of 25. Just make three pies, to be honest.

How much does a Costco pumpkin pie feed?

While there are officially 12 servings per container, I believe you could easily feed more people with this stuff. The pie crust is prepared in-house, according to The Costco Connection.

How long should pumpkin pie sit before serving?

Pies’ sides and bottoms may seem chilly to the touch due to their density, but the interior remains relatively warm. Follow this advice: Pumpkin pie solidifies as it cools, so allow it to cool for at least four hours for a beautiful pie slice.

Can you make money selling pies?

Even if you’re a novice baker, pies are a pretty simple item to sell in order to earn money. When selling pies from home, however, you must follow your state and county local cottage food rules.

How much pie for 8 people?

A 9-inch pie feeds 8 people.

How much pie for 10 people?

To put it simply, a family should eat one whole pie for every six people at the table.

Why are pumpkin pies so expensive?

When it comes to pumpkin-flavored foods, customers can expect to pay more. The seasonal favorite is subject to the “pumpkin spice tax,” which means businesses hike pricing on certain things – whether cookies, lattes, or even dog treats – due to high demand.

Which state eats the most pumpkin pies?

Residents of North Carolina, Michigan, Maryland, Wisconsin, Kentucky, Oklahoma, Iowa, Nebraska, West Virginia, Mississippi, and South Dakota are the most fond of pumpkin pie.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *