Best Chicken Sandwich Sauce [List of 18 Options]

They make paradise in a matter of minutes by just putting it in the centre of two pieces of bread spruced up with lettuce and cheese. Even the finest ideas may benefit from refinement, which in this instance means saucing it up. So, what sauces complement a chicken sandwich?

There are several sauces that go great with a chicken sandwich. Among the greatest chicken sandwich sauces are honey mustard sauce, lemon and garlic sauce, mayo and curry sauce, marinara, barbecue sauce, garlic, lemon, parsley, tzatziki, tartar sauce, sweet marinara sauce, Alfredo sauce, and honey and beer sauce.

I’ll offer you some sauce suggestions for your chicken sandwich in the next paragraphs.

Best Sauce for Fried Chicken Sandwich 

Fried chicken sandwiches are juicy, as well as fatty and oily. They’re tasty, little crunchy, and delicious. The sauces that follow add to the juiciness of the fried chicken sandwich by complimenting and enhancing the tastes.

Honey Mustard

Honey mustard sauce is one of the greatest combinations for fried chicken and is often served with chicken nuggets and wings. The quantities are rather flexible, but be sure to carefully balance the flavors so that the honey taste does not overpower but rather follows the tone established by the mustard.

In addition to the honey mustard, you’ll need some salt and pepper, as well as some water if the sauce becomes too thick. Some people prefer to add ketchup to their honey mustard sauce, so you may try that as well.

Lemon Garlic 

This sauce is delicious on fried chicken sandwiches and is made with just lemon juice, garlic, and oil. The garlic and lemon combo adds its magic to the narrative and intensifies the tastes already contained in the sandwich. It’s simple to create and perfectly complements the fried chicken sandwich.

To balance the lemon and garlic tastes, add pickles or olives to your fried chicken sandwich. With only a squeeze of lemon, minced garlic, and a drizzle of oil to bind the ingredients, you’ll have a tasty and zesty sauce in under a minute.

Mayo and Curry 

Fried chicken sandwiches pair well with mayo and curry tastes. These two components work beautifully together since they are very flexible, tasty, and compatible.

Simply combine the curry powder and mayonnaise until the curry powder is evenly distributed throughout the mayonnaise consistency. This sauce takes some major elbow grease to prepare, but it is well worth it since careful mixing makes the mayo consistency less pungent and more enjoyable to consume.

Best Sauce for Grilled Chicken Sandwich 

Grilled chicken is one of the most adaptable and ubiquitous sandwich fillings. It works well with any salad, sauce, or condiment. Even though you may pair a grilled chicken sandwich with almost every sauce you can think of, the ones listed below are among the tastiest.

Barbeque Sauce 

One of the greatest sauces for grilled chicken sandwiches created with spicy sauce, red pepper, spices, and vinegar is Carolina BBQ sauce. It works best if prepared ahead of time so that it can set in the fridge.

Simply combine the ingredients, putting the vinegar last and the spicy sauce first. Dosage the spices such that none of them overpower the sauce by adding them gently and tasting it periodically.

This sauce is also long-lasting, so prepare a jar and store it in the fridge for a week to enjoy as many grilled chicken sandwiches as you like.

Soy Sauce With Herbs and Honey

If you don’t feel very creative but want to treat yourself to a great chicken sandwich and sauce combination, this is the recipe for you. Combining the distinct soy tang with the sweetness of honey and the natural and earthy aromas of the herbs will elevate your grilled chicken sandwich to new heights.

If you just need basic culinary abilities, you will have no issue creating this sauce. Mix the honey and soy sauce well. Add the honey and soy sauce second, followed by the herbs.

Garlic, Lemon, and Parsley 

Combine melted butter, chopped garlic, and parsley in a mixing bowl, then top with a few freshly squeezed lemon drops. The sauce’s butteriness will soften the strength of the lemon and garlic flavors while emphasizing the parsley taste.

You’ll appreciate the zing this sauce gives to your sandwich, whether you slather it over your sandwich buns or just soak it after every mouthful.

Best Sauce for Deli Chicken Sandwich 

Many people love the deli chicken sandwich since it is one of the most popular meals ever. Whether you’re late for work and need a fast bite to eat or you’re in the midst of a hectic day, the deli chicken sandwich is always a tasty way to fill your tummy.

Mayo and Mustard

Mayonnaise and mustard are examples of incredibly basic sauces. Given how wonderful this combo is, there’s no way you’d imagine it’s that simple to create. Combine the mayonnaise and mustard, as well as your desired amount of the other ingredients to balance the tastes, and you’re ready to go.

Tomato Sauce (Marinara)

If you have some extra time, marinara sauce is a wonderful way to enhance your deli chicken sandwich. Simply puree a few tomatoes and cook them in a pot over high oil. Season with garlic, herbs, salt, and pepper to taste.

Allow the marinara sauce to cool and thicken somewhat before enjoying the taste explosion in your tongue as the sauce’s liquid and the deli chicken mingle in perfect harmony.

Olives and Sour Cream 

With its brightness, zest, zing, and subtle edge, olive and sour cream is a deliciously refreshing combination that has captured the hearts of many. All you have to do is puree the olives and combine them with the sour cream.

The olive brine will react with the sour cream, thinned it out and transforming it into a wonderfully balanced combination that you can apply over your sandwich buns and enjoy the fresh and meaty tastes.

Best Sauce for Chicken Salad Sandwich

It’s extremely likely that you have some leftover chicken salad in your fridge, particularly during the Christmas season. Instead than enjoying it in the same form and shape till it’s gone, try constructing a chicken salad sandwich supplemented with some of the sauce options below.

Tartar 

Because chicken salad contains pickles, they define the flavor and establish the tone, so you need a sauce that maintains the same mood while adding a little character of its own. Here comes the tartar sauce.

This sauce is a classic for a reason: it’s made with mayo and shredded pickles, seasoned with pepper and maybe some powdered garlic. It’s creamy, rich, juicy, and really tasty. With this sauce, your chicken salad will move from rich to decadent, generating a tiny slice of paradise from your sandwich.

Tzatziki 

The tzatziki sauce demonstrates the power of herbs, Greek yogurt, and a little love. Mix the Greek yogurt with herbs of your choice, such as thyme and dill, and enjoy the fun tastes competing for a short spell in the limelight.

The tzatziki sauce adds a Mediterranean flavor to your chicken salad sandwich, filling your tongue with creamy textures, crunchy surprises, and creamy bliss.

Sour Cream and Mayo

A simple combination of sour cream and mayonnaise may be all you need to enrich and improve your chicken salad sandwich. Your sauce is done when you combine the mayo and sour cream.

This delicate sauce will soften your chicken salad sandwich while toning down the sharpness of the pickles and boosting the flavor of the chicken salad.

Best Sauce for Spicy Chicken Sandwich

A spicy chicken sandwich is tangy, fiery, and flavorful. Mixing spices, tastes, scents, and styles may range from mild to severely spicy, depending on your preferences. When adding sauce to a spicy chicken sandwich, use as little force as possible to avoid overpowering the taste.

The following sauces might help you.

Sour Cream and Herbs

Yes, it’s as easy as it sounds. Sour cream and herbs may make all the difference in the world when it comes to enhancing your spicy chicken sandwich. The sour cream’s moderate smoothness will assist to tone down any too strong tastes, while the herbs will provide some sweetness to the sandwich.

Sweet Tomato Sauce 

Something about spice and sweetness complements each other well. Sweet tomato sauce, like marinara sauce, is marinara with sugar. Sugar sweetens the sauce, which subsequently sweetens the hot chicken sandwich.

All you have to do is puree the tomatoes in hot oil and add a tablespoon of brown sugar. The sugar will thicken the sweet tomato sauce even more, making it the ideal complement to your spicy chicken sandwich.

Honey Beer 

Keep this combination in mind the next time you want to glaze chicken since it can be used as both a sauce and a glaze. This sauce involves considerable cooking, but if you have the time and energy, it is well worth the effort.

First, heat up some oil in a pan. Allow the honey and soy sauce to melt completely before adding the honey. Then, add the thyme, and last, the beer. Stir everything together and cook for a minute.

Remove the pan from the heat and set aside to cool. Enjoy.

Best Sauce for Shredded Chicken Sandwich

A shredded chicken sandwich may be prepared using grilled, fried, or spicy chicken, therefore any of the sauces listed above would suffice. However, the three sauces listed below will provide you with a solid starting point.

Alfredo 

This sauce, prepared with butter, heavy cream, parmesan, Italian seasoning, and chopped garlic, is a fantastic accompaniment to a shredded chicken sandwich. Melt the butter in a saucepan and whisk in the minced garlic and cream until smooth.

Allow them to boil for a minute or two before adding the parmesan. Allow the sauce to cool after thoroughly mixing everything. Spread a thick coating of this delicacy on your sandwich bread and enjoy the sweetness that this sandwich provides.

Cream of Champignon 

Although cream of champignon is essentially a soup, adding less water thickens it and transforms it into a true sauce. You may also add cooking cream to this sauce to make it more creamy. The expressive mushroom taste will complement your shredded chicken sandwich excellently.

Curry Sauce  

To create the curry sauce, sauté the onions and garlic in butter until softened. Then, in the saucepan, combine the curry powder and boiling cream. When the sauce’s consistency is smooth and creamy, you’ll know it’s done.

Smear it on your sandwich bread and serve with curry-flavored shredded chicken.