13 Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Mix Add-Ins

Rate this post

Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Mix is delicious on its own, but you can always enhance and enrich your cookies. Several ingredients may be used to enhance the flavor and texture of your cookies. So, what can you put in Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Mix?

Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Mix may be flavored with coffee, spices, sour cream, lemon zest, cereal, chocolate, peanut butter, sweets, and nuts. To change the consistency and texture of the cookies, add additional milk, eggs, butter, sugar, or flour.

Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Mix is a terrific method to bake excellent cookies, and it’s even better since you can customize them. Yet, flavor isn’t necessarily the reason to utilize add-ins; the dough itself may need some assistance. In the following text, I will discuss Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Mix add-ins and why you should use them.

If you want to make your Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Mix even better than it currently is, you may add one or more of the following ingredients.

Dried Fruit 

Dried fruit such as cranberries, raisins, pineapple, or any other dried fruit you want make excellent additions to Betty Crocker sugar cookies. Because of the sugar in these components, they will thicken the batter and give the cookie a lovely caramel taste.

Peanut Butter 

Peanut butter will go well with your sugar cookies, but it will alter the flavor. The salt from peanuts brings out the sweetness and gives your visitors the impression that they were cooked from scratch! The flavor may also make you think of Betty Crocker Peanut Butter Cookies.

Moreover, peanut butter will make the texture firmer, giving you thinner and more chewy cookies, but it will limit your ability to combine them.

Grated Apples 

Grated apple is an excellent method to bring freshness and fruitiness to your cookies. You may grate the apple and add it right now, bake it and mash it before adding it, or grate it, caramelize it, and then add it to the rest of the ingredients.

Whichever choice you pick, your cookies will taste delicious.

Nevertheless, if you want to incorporate the shredded caramelized apples, use less sugar since the sugar from the caramelized apples may make your cookies overly sweet.

In addition, if your cookie dough is too runny, add two teaspoons of flour to thicken it up. Be cautious with the measurements, since the dough might get too dry.


Add some instant coffee diluted in hot water to chocolate biscuits. The coffee will turn the dough brown, making the cookies more chocolaty. It will also lend bitterness to the cookies, which complements the chocolate taste well.

Moreover, the hot water will work as a bonding agent, activating the mixture quickly.


In cookies, nutmeg, cinnamon, pumpkin spice, or powdered ginger go a long way. But, since they are rather potent, they will most likely overpower the cookie taste. Dry spices will not impact the consistency of the dough, so don’t worry about adding too much, however flavor is important.

Before adding the liquids and creating the dough, always add the spices to the dry mix. This ensures that they are equally distributed and that all cookies have a comparable flavor.

Sour Cream

Sour cream and baked goodies are always welcome guests. Sour cream makes the cookies creamier, softer, and lighter, reducing the likelihood of their burning.

To avoid lumps from developing, whisk the sour cream before combining it with the other ingredients. The sour cream will not overpower the taste, but it will be discernible, providing a touch of freshness to the cookies, which will be particularly apparent when they are cold.

Citrus Zest

Lemon, orange, or grapefruit zest will greatly enhance your cookie batter. These will sour the cookies, making them ideal for anything you want to pair them with, even a glass of milk.


A few teaspoons of vanilla, almond, or whatever essence you want can transform your Betty Crocker sugar cookies into a piece of beauty. Your cookies will have a slight print of the extract you use, but it will not overpower or dominate them.

A mixture of extracts is also effective. To ensure that the flavors are distributed equally throughout the cookie dough, combine the extracts and add them to the liquid components before combining them with the dry.

Crunchy Cereal 

Cereals mixed with sugar cookie dough may be a fantastic treat for the taste buds. These not only provide crunch, but they also make the cookies lighter since they contain air bubbles in their structure.

A cup of cornflakes, fruity loops, or any cereal brand that you like will enough to enhance your cookies.


Before combining the dry and liquid components, mix in the espresso powder. The espresso powder will bitteren the mixture and give the cookies a kick, making them ideal for morning.


You may make your cookies more exciting and tasty by adding chocolate chips, M&Ms, rainbow sprinkles, marshmallows, or dried fruit to the batter. The chocolate will melt and lend richness to the cookies. The dried fruit will add more sugar to the cookies, caramelizing the exterior.

Crushed Nuts

Consider making your Betty Crocker sugar cookies with bits of almonds, hazelnuts, or nuts, or all three. The pieces will roast perfectly within and on top of the cookies, creating delightfully moist holes where they baked.

The cookies’ structure will be crumbly, and the chunks will compensate for any crunchiness lost due to the other components.


Adding pudding to your cookies will not only change the taste but also the texture, making it chewy and gooey, giving you the right combination of cookies and fudge.

It is not always enough to just add ingredients to enhance your Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Mix; sometimes the key is technique.

Include Milk

When you add milk to your sugar cookie mix, the cookies become softer and moister on the inside and smoother on the exterior. It also has an effect on taste, making the other tastes softer and more balanced.

But, watch how much milk you add and equalize the consistency by adding four if you go too far.

Add Extra Eggs

One or two more eggs will aid in the bonding of the other components, resulting in more sturdy cookies with greater flexibility. But, keep in mind that eggs lessen the crumbliness of the cookies.

If you like crumbly cookies but still want to use eggs, add crushed almonds to compensate.

Make Cookies With Butter

When it comes to baked products, butter is unrivaled. Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Mix uses either butter, margarine, or spread. Instead of the other two, use genuine butter.

Another component cannot replace the butter’s internal creaminess, outer smoothness, and fattiness. Butter also makes the dough simpler to deal with and minimizes the likelihood of sticky cookies.

Put Some Flour 

The addition of flour helps to level out the viscosity of the sugar cookie mix. If you add too many liquid components, add flour to balance the consistency.

To prevent lumps, always sift the flour into the mixture. While baking, lumps tend to burn, which might spoil your cookies.

Freeze the Dough 

Since the dough may be unstable regardless of what you add, you must do something to stabilize it, particularly if you are producing cut-outs.

Refrigerating the dough for a couple of hours before baking the cookies may be precisely what they require. Also, chilling the dough adds moisture, making the cookies softer and juicier.

Decrease the Baking Time

Lowering the baking time to as short as five minutes may enhance your cookies greatly, particularly if you want them softer.

Improve Cookies With Frosting 

Nothing icing can’t cure, no matter what faults you made with the dough. As a result, if nothing else works, don’t skimp on the icing.


How to improve Betty Crocker sugar cookie mix?

When mixed into your sugar cookie recipe, a teaspoon or two of extracts will substantially improve the taste. The obvious option is vanilla. Add vanilla and almond extracts for a more interesting taste. Some delectable flavors to consider are rum, maple, and anise.

What to add to boxed sugar cookie mix?

You can quickly transform your sugar cookie dough into gourmet delights by adding nuts, chocolate chips, citrus zest, toffee pieces, extracts, or spices, whether using your favorite recipe or pre-made.

What needs to be added to cookie mix?

A box of cookie dough is just a carton of dry ingredients. A box mix recipe usually calls for simply eggs and butter, but A Good Tired blog suggests you shouldn’t stop there. To enhance the taste profile of the box mix dough, add milk, vanilla, oats, and a little amount of coconut oil.

How do you add flavor to sugar cookies?

4 teaspoon ginger. Sugar Cookies with Orange, Lemon, or Lime Zest. To give your sugar cookies a zesty taste, add a tablespoon of zest and a teaspoon of orange flavor, lemon flavor, or lime flavor. 1 teaspoon excellent grade cinnamon, 4 teaspoon ground nutmeg 1

How do you elevate Betty Crocker cookie mix?

These are some simple changes you can make to give your cookie mix a handmade flavor.
… Use margarine or shortening in place of butter in a 1:1 ratio…. Coconut oil instead of other fats…. Maple syrup instead of granulated sugar…. Vanilla extract…. Almond extract…. Rum and Ginger…. Cheesecake.
More to come…
•Sep 12, 2022

How do I get better at decorating sugar cookies?

Learn the Art of Icing Consistency. The most common decorating blunder is inconsistent icing consistency.
Keep the equipment as simple as possible. Don’t purchase too much equipment straight soon…. Discover a Recipe That Works for You.
Roll the Dough to a Quarter-Inch Thickness…. Use Gel Food Coloring…. Practice Piping and Develop a Strategy.
Initially, pipe straight lines. Next, learn to turn.
More to come…
•Dec 4, 2018

What happens when you add an extra egg to cookies?

Egg yolks provide taste and texture to chocolate chip cookies because they contain lecithin and fat. If you want your cookies chewy rather than crispy, adding additional yolks will result in a softer and more tender final product, and the leftover whites may be saved for another dessert or meal.

Can you add an egg to Betty Crocker cookie mix?

3 cup oil, 2 teaspoons water and 1 egg. Betty’s Tip: To prepare using vegetable oil, make dough with 1 cup vegetable oil.

How do you make cookies taste better?

But what about simple sweet or salty snacks? Bring it with you. Caramel or normal popcorn, salty potato chips, and pretzels are all excellent additions; just crush any big bits as you add them to the dough. That may be old hat by now, but salt does make cookies taste better.

What do you need for the Betty Crocker cookie mix?

4 cup) 1 butter, margarine, or spread (at least 60% vegetable oil in spread) (To soften butter immediately from the refrigerator. 10-15 seconds in a high-powered microwave) (Not Melted). 1 Tablespoon water. 1 stick (1 instruction. Bake: You will require: 1

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *